Ijtihad, past-present
45 - IJTIHAD: Today,
many of the symptoms of the end of the world have appeared and spread far
and wide. One of these symptoms is that the number of the ignorant will
increase and men of knowledge will decrease. The ignorant will be authorities
in the religion and lead everybody astray. These symptoms are written in
detail in the hadiths written in Mukhtasar at-tazkirat al-Qurtubi and in
al-Birghiwi's Wasiyyat-nama. Then, Muslims should be vigilant. They should
not believe in every word. They should not believe those who do not mention
the Ahl as-Sunnat scholars and their books but extract meanings from ayats
and hadiths according to their own minds in their khutba, books and papers.
The non-madhhabite people are either heretics or unbelievers, both of whom
have always disguised themselves as religious men and deceived Muslims
and led them astray. We should search for the meanings which the Ahl as-Sunnat
scholars have given to the ayats and hadiths about which those heretical
people talk and should learn the truth of the matter. For doing this, we
should read the dependable 'ilm al-hal books. The Ahl as-Sunnat scholars
have studied all the ayats and hadiths minutely, found out their true meanings
by splitting hairs and written them down in books. Now the ignorant of
religion who know little Arabic assume themselves to be mujtahids. By saying,
"We have graduated from the university; we have received diploma," they
despise Islamic scholars. Whereas, if a teaching which the mujtahids of
a period have reported as ijma', that is, unanimously, is one of the fundamentals
of the religion, that is, if it has spread everywhere so that even the
ignorant know it, it is fard both to believe and to follow it. He who does
not believe such an ijma' becomes an unbeliever. He who believes but does
not follow it becomes a fasiq. If a unanimously reported teaching is not
one of the fundamentals of the religion, he who disbelieves it does not
become an unbeliever. He becomes a heretic, a man of bidat. He who does
not follow it becomes a fasiq, a sinner.
Ibn Malak wrote
on ijma' in his book Usul al-fiqh, "If the mujtahids of a certain era did
not agree on how an action should be done and explained it differently,
the scholars succeeding them should follow the words of one of them and
is not permissible for them to say differently. All scholars have said
unanimously that it must be so and thus ijma' has resulted." There is not
a mujtahid in any part of the world today. 'Mujtahid' means 'an Islamic
scholar who has attained to the grade of ijtihad'. Not from ourselves do
we say that there is no mujtahid on the earth today; all scholars have
been declaring this, including Hadrat Shah Wali-Allah ad-Dahlawi, of whom
Mawdudi tries to make a false witness. For example, Ibn 'Abidin, while
commenting on the statement, "To call very loud for the muazzins will spoil
their salat," in Durr al-mukhtar, wrote: "After 400 years following Rasulullah's
('alaihi 's-salam) death there has come no great scholar to do qiyas, and
no mutlaq mujtahid who could derive rules by comparing one affair to another
came." As declared in the Hadith, profound scholars who would attain to
the grade of ijtihad would come every hundred years, but these have been
the mujtahids within a madhhab, who have not undertaken the task of doing
qiyas, that is, performing new ijtihad, but have tried to renovate the
ijtihad of the leader of the madhhab to which they have belonged and to
lead people to the right course, seeing that there was no need for new
ijtihad and being interested in emphasizing the Ahl as-Sunnat knowledge.
A Muslim who is not a mujtahid is called a muqallid (follower). Today,
we all the Muslims on the earth are muqallids. No matter how much learned
a muqallid is, he cannot do ijtihad over a matter disagreeing with what
the mujtahids have communicated before; this is understood from the unanimity
quoted from Ibn Malak above. The hadith, "My umma will not agree on deviation,"
indicates that this unanimity of scholars is a means of salvation and is
correct. |